Capturing context for qualitative data
On 3 May 2006 ESDS Qualidata held a workshop as part of the QUADS Demonstrator scheme
to address the issue of defining and capturing data context.
Defining how to provide context for raw data to make it more 'usable' is a complex and
sometimes contentious topic that been the focus of some heated debates within
the qualitative data community. ESDS Qualidata has spent 10 years working in the area of sharing qualitative data,
and has done much to establish informal ways of documenting raw data, such as
interview texts and field notes. In addition to written materials arising out of the project, interviews with
depositors have proved to be one of the most effective ways of capturing
context. Contextual needs for 'raw data' depend on the particular intended usage: description; comparative research,
restudy or follow-up study; augmenting new data collection; re-analysis or
secondary analysis; verification; research design and methodological
advancement; or teaching and learning.
Situating data in its context requires both micro and macro level features to be considered
including: how the research question was framed; the research application
process; project progress; fieldwork situations; analyses, processes and
output/publication activities. For example, when undertaking a replication or restudy, detailed information on
sampling procedures, fieldwork approaches and question guides is essential.
The day fostered an opportunity for QUADS projects to share experiences from work in progress. The
workshop gave some useful input into consensus on mandatory elements for
providing necessary context.
ESDS Qualidata is planning three main outcomes arising from this workshop:
- a series of papers published in the first issue of the new journal Methodological Innovations
- a minimal agreed set of elements that define context for metadata as it relates to different kinds of data
- a guide to best practice with advice on capturing context as it relates to different kinds of secondary analysis and data re-use scenarios
Presentations from the day are available from ESDS
Qualidata events.
Online Qualitative Data Resources: Best Practice in Metadata Creation and Web Standards
On 15 November 2005 ESDS Qualidata hosted its first workshop as co-ordinators of the
Qualitative Archiving and Data Sharing Scheme (QUADS). The event focused on: the
fundamentals of presenting qualitative data resources on the web; longer-term
sharing and archiving; and promoting standards including building sustainable
web sites, harmonising data descriptions, and marking up data
content.
Web standards are important - good practice in web design and
usability builds on compliance with World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) guidelines
and Web Content Accessibility Guidelines. Equally, metadata plays a crucial role
in the identification, retrieval, management and long-term storage of digital
qualitative data. Consensus is needed to ensure common ways of describing
resources, so that resource discovery strategies, for example, can be pooled.
Marking up of data, using universal (eXtended Markup Language(XML))
standards, enables richer and deeper navigation, searching and retrieval at the
data content level. Mark-up, at the data level, enables coded textual documents,
links from text to audio excerpts, and researcher annotations, to be retained.
Mark-up is also important for longer-term storage and preservation and
more complex collaborative research and escience type exploitation.
ESDS
Qualidata presented an overview of the merits of metadata for social science and
proposed an XML community standard (schema) that is applicable to most
qualitative data. Feedback on the schema would be welcomed. To add an applied
dimension to the day, four projects, currently creating online resources for
qualitative data collections using XML, provided an informal overview of their
work.
Presentations from the day are available from the ESDS Qualidata events page.
QUADS Advisory Committee meeting
12 July 2005 MRC London (1pm - 4pm)
Initial QUADS project meeting
12 May 2005 MRC London (1pm - 4pm)
QUADS Advisory Committee meeting
15 September 2005 RSS London (1pm - 4pm)